NY Times: Amtrak Breakup Advances

What do you think this really means? Will it really happen? When? How do you think the (ever-changing and mysterious) announcements of fare increases play into this? -- David

Full article

October 13, 2005

Amtrak Breakup Advances

By MATTHEW L. WALD

WASHINGTON, Oct. 12 - The Amtrak board has approved an essential step in the Bush administration plan to break up the railroad, voting to carve out the Northeast Corridor, the tracks between Boston and Washington, as a separate division.

The board, made up entirely of Mr. Bush's appointees, voted in a meeting on Sept. 22 to create a new subsidiary to own and manage the corridor, which includes nearly all the track that Amtrak owns.

The vote was not announced. It was reported on Wednesday in the newsletter of the United Rail Passenger Alliance of Jacksonville, Fla., an organization that has been highly critical of Amtrak management.

The plan, which would require action by Congress, is to transfer the corridor to a consortium including the federal government and the governments of the states in the region that would share the costs to maintain it.

That would relieve Amtrak from spending billions of dollars to build and rebuild bridges, rails and electrical systems, but still let the company run its trains.

The plan would also remove Amtrak from control of that sector, a condition that the railroad's senior executives say would doom high-speed long-distance service. Managers say they have to be able to give their trains priority over local traffic if they have any hope of keeping their schedules.

A large majority of trains in the corridor are shorter-distance commuter trains operated by state agencies in metropolitan regions, although Amtrak trains accrue a majority of the miles traveled.

The four-member board has shown ambivalence to some aspects of the administration's proposal.

On April 21, the chairman, David M. Laney, testified before a Senate committee, "We have concluded for now that the complexities and risks associated with such a split outweigh any benefits."

In a telephone interview on Wednesday, Mr. Laney denied that the vote to make the corridor a separate operating division was a precursor to separating it from Amtrak entirely.

No one actually knows how much the increase will be...

I bought a monthly commuter pass for November this morning and was charged the old rate. I asked when and how much the fare increase would be and was told that the increase would begin on October 16th -- but that the people working at the ticket counter still don't know what it will be!

It's still very unclear what the Amtrak management is planning to do.

Philly commuters are mad about the increase too...

Philly.com has a good article on how the fare increase will affect commuters to NYC:

Nearly 700 Philadelphia-area residents take on the commute, according to Amtrak, and these days they're a pretty angry bunch.

Amtrak intends to boost the cost of monthly Philadelphia-to-New York passes from $633 to $1,008 - beyond the break-even point for many commuters, who say the increase threatens not just their income but their jobs. As riders consider switching to cheaper-but-longer commutes aboard buses or NJ Transit trains, the rate increase jeopardizes something else too, something subtle and intangible: The culture of the train.

The people who ride to New York in the morning and back to Philadelphia at night make up a kind of community within a community, spending three to four hours a day encased within the same speeding steel tube. Some spend more time with each other than they do with their kids.

Like other commuters, she's furious about the fare increase. Some people worry they'll have to quit their jobs. Who can afford $12,000 a year to get to work?